Summer Series Part 1: Updated March 2017
- Protecting Little Skins
- Babies 0-6 Months
- Baby Sunscreen 101
- Best Lotions
- Best Sprays
- Sunscreen Controversies
With so many conflicting recommendations out there about SUN, babies, and sunscreen, it’s hard to know what to do. Thus: The Official Lucie’s List Guide to Summer Fun. Holllerrr!
Protecting Little Skins
Since unprotected sun exposure is the most preventable risk factor for skin cancer, it’s something to take pretty seriously. Heck, I wish someone had given me the memo about this when I was a young ‘un; maybe I would have reconsidered daily tanning (burning?) contests with my sister. As someone who grew up in the South, LIVING at the pool every day… let’s just say we can do better with this generation of kids.
But it’s not just skin. In fact, “children under 10 are at a high risk for… eye damage from UV rays. And until about age 10, the lens of a child’s eye is clear, allowing greater solar penetration and thus greater UVR-induced ocular changes,” explains Adelaide A. Hebert, MD, professor and vice chair of dermatology, University of Texas Medical Center at Houston [SkinCancer.org].
Babies 0 – 6 Months Old
“I’ve read I can’t use sunscreen until 6 months, and I’ve got a family beach vacation coming up. What should I do?”
It’s true that the AAD (American Academy of Dermatology) recommends keeping babies < 6 months out of the sun and using minimal amounts of sunscreen, but don’t cancel your beach vacation [oh no]… just bring along an umbrella or a sun tent and use hats, protective clothing, and small amounts of sunscreen when you must.
At 3 weeks old, [then] baby Alice spent many an afternoon chilling in our beach tent and wiggling around in the sand. If you’re on a budget, I recommend the Coleman Road Trip Beach Shade (below). If you can spend a little more ($65-ish), the Pacific Breeze EasyUp Beach Tent is the most highly rated. It too is UPF 50 and is super easy to get up and take down.
Just make sure the material is UV rated; otherwise, your baby can still get burned through the tent material. FYI, they can also get burned from sun reflecting off the sand and water.
Baby Sunscreen 101
Sunscreen vs. Sunblock
Technically speaking, sunscreens use chemicals to absorb UV rays so they don’t penetrate the skin, while sunblocks use minerals, such as titanium dioxide or zinc oxide to physically deflect rays from the skin. However, these terms are often used interchangeably, so it’s a little confusing. Case in point: all of the recommended kids’ “sunscreens” below are technically sunblocks. But they’re called sunscreens. So, yeah, just… FYI.
Sunblocks are generally recommended for babies and children (over sunscreens) by pediatricians, advocacy groups, environmentalists, etc. for various reasons [read more below in “sunscreen controversies“].
The general sentiment is something like this: “A natural mineral (aka physical) sunblock is, by far, the safest option to get your SPF. The minerals zinc and titanium sit on the skin’s surface and reflect sun rays out away from the body like tin foil. Chemical ingredients [found in sunscreens] are absorbed into the skin to deal with sun rays in a chemically reactive process in the skin cell itself, with potentially unintended and harmful consequences to the skin and body,” says Kim Walls, M.S.
The downside to sunblocks is that they are generally more expensive because of the cost of the minerals used to make them. Just note that a little goes a long way, and a single tube or two can last you the whole season.
Screens and blocks for kids come in lotions, sprays, and sticks.
Everyone has their preferences, but I prefer lotions for infants — and sprays for kids-who-can’t-sit-still. The best way to do it is to apply sunscreen before you dress your child so you can get all the nooks and crannies (for girls, under swimsuit straps, etc.).
The Best Sunblocks for Babies, Toddlers, and Children
How did we decide? We weighed input from SkinCancer.org, EWG (Environmental Working Group), Consumer Reports, and loads of user reviews. Read below for the recommendations for “sunscreen controversies.”
For whatever reason, some of these products are a bit hard to find (e.g., most are definitely not found at your local Walgreens or Piggly Wiggly. Sorry).
Thinkbaby Sunscreen SPF 50+ ~ $11 (3 oz)
The best kid’s sunscreen ever and the highest-rated baby sunscreen on multiple sites, with over 1,000 reviews on Amazon averaging 4.3/5 stars, Thinkbaby offers broad spectrum UVA/UVB protection with SPF 50+, and it’s “very water resistant” (up to 80 minutes in the water). Thinkbaby is paraben and PABA-free, and it received an “excellent” for UVA and SPF protection from EWG’s “Skin Deep” scores.
Best of all, I should note that many sunscreens (especially the mineral sunblocks) look great on paper, but may have a terrible consistency (sticky, goopy, etc.) when you apply it. Thinkbaby has a nice, creamy consistency and is super easy to apply, which is another reason it’s our #1 (for 3 years running, in fact).
~ Can also be found at your local Whole Foods and Walgreens.com. *Note that Thinkbaby and Thinksport are exactly the same formula. They just want to confuse us, of course!
* Active ingredient: Zinc Oxide 20% [Non-nano]
Blue Lizard Sensitive (or Baby) Sunscreen – SPF 30+ ~ $23 (8.75 oz)
Fair-skinned people living under a giant hole in the ozone know how to avoid a sunburn (slip, slap, slop!). Blue Lizard has been our go-to sunscreen since Lucie was born. This sensitive skin formulation, with no chemical absorbers, offers broad photostable UVA/UVB protection and protects skin for up to 4 hours of activity. Paraben and PABA-free.
* If water resistance is of the utmost importance, check out the Sport version, which is water resistant up to 240 minutes. To be honest, nobody can tell us what the difference is in the “Baby” vs. “Sensitive” versions of this product, so I get whichever one is cheaper.
* Active ingredients ~ 10% Zinc Oxide and 5% Titanium Dioxide [Non-nano]
Badger Baby Sunscreen Cream SPF 30 ~ $13 (2.9 oz)
The highest-rated of the all-natural and organic, earthy mama sunscreens is Badger Baby. If you can get over the scent and the pasty texture, this is a very high-performing sunscreen whose ingredients are as crunchy as they come. I’ll admit, the base of sunflower oil, beeswax, and vitamin E is rather soothing. Yes, it’s water resistant for at least 40 minutes.
* The thing about Badger is that you really need to shake it well because it tends to separate if it’s sitting on the shelf too long. Like I said, not my favorite consistency, but they have a great reputation.
* Active Ingredient ~ Uncoated Zinc Oxide 18.75% [Non-nano]
In my opinion, sprays are sometimes easier to apply because I can hold the victim down with one hand (or hold her hair back) and spray her with the other, mwaaa. I do it outside so it doesn’t get everywhere. Mommy’s got spray and she isn’t afraid to use it!
Mind you, these sprays still have to be rubbed in, unlike some of the toxic adult versions. Kidding (sort of). Just be sure they’re not inhaling it.
BabyGanics Mineral-Based Sunscreen Spray SPF 50+ ~ $19 (pack of 2! 6 oz)
Water resistant for 80 minutes and SPF 50+, this kid-friendly sunscreen is great for long days at the beach or pool. Contains no PABA, parabens, or phthalates. It offers broad spectrum UVA/UVB protection and is easy to apply. Non-allergenic and tear free. * Also available as a stick
Again, the big benefit of using a spray is that I can hold my kid’s hair (or swimsuit straps) while I spray with one hand. With lotions and creams, you most definitely need to use two hands. It’s this convenience that I like. There are some reviews saying it doesn’t work well, but that has never been my experience.
* There is a concern about using sprays with nano-particles on children because they could be inhaled. This formulation is non-nano — but regardless, make sure your child doesn’t inhale it (or any other sprays, for that matter).
* Active ingredients ~ Octinoxate 7.5%, Octisalate 5.0%, Zinc Oxide 11.2% [Non-nano]
FYI — There are lots of good sunblocks out there, but many of them are only available through specialty websites. We’re not recommending Honest Sunscreen (obviously) due to the debacle from last summer (thought they do have a new formula out in 2017). Not recommending California Baby because it is expensive and not well-loved by reviewers. Do you have one you love? Please leave a comment below, thanks!
Remember: Sunscreen is just part of the equation that also includes protective clothing, hat and eye protection, and staying out of the sun when the rays are strongest, between 10 am and 3 pm, generally.
The three main controversies of sunscreens (particularly for children) look something like this:
The Nanoparticle Debate
Over the past few years, there’s been a lot of talk about the safety of “nanoparticles.” You see, in the past, mineral sunblocks consisted of large enough particles so that they always remained white and chalky on the skin. More recently, many products have been formulated to reduce the size of the mineral particles, called nanoparticles, making them less visible on the skin. No more ghostly white-face — yay, right?
However, there are concerns that nanoparticles may possibly pass THROUGH the skin (especially in pre-term babies and very young babies) and may be photo-reactive, forming free radicals that can cause cell damage. Those espousing this position recommend using only mineral sunblocks that contain “micronized” particles rather than nanoparticles. [Technically, a nanoparticle is any particle less than 100 nanometers in diameter, but a particle must actually be less than 50 nanometers to enter skin cells, less than 70 nanometers to enter the lungs, etc.] Got it? Okay good.
Essentially, the jury is still out on this, folks. The American Academy of Dermatology [AAD] says, “Considerable research on the use of nanoparticles on healthy, undamaged skin has shown that the stratum corneum – the outermost layer of the skin – is an effective barrier to preventing the entry of nanoparticles into the deeper layers of the skin” [AAD, 2012]. Still, others suggest otherwise. Basically, nobody knows for sure. *All the products I recommend [above] are NON-nano (in case you were wondering what the heck that means). No she-NANO-gans here, mama. 😉 I’m hilarious, I know.
*Update for 2017: I have been assured by a couple of readers (who are toxicologists or married to someone who is) that nano-particles are not harmful to humans, even babies. Please read below in the comments. See also here.
The good news is that oxybenzone is one of the few FDA-approved ingredients that provide effective broad-spectrum protection (see #3) from UV radiation. The bad news is that oxybenzone might be an endocrine disruptor, which could affect the nervous system, has been linked to cancer in some laboratory studies, and creates free-radicals when exposed to the sun. Woohoo!
The jury is out on this one as well. According to the AAD, “Available peer-reviewed scientific literature and regulatory assessments from national and international bodies do not support a link between oxybenzone in sunscreen and hormonal alterations, or other significant health issues in humans,” claims Dr. Siegel [AAD, 2012].
However, many pediatricians warn parents to avoid oxybenzone. So… yeah. *All of the products we recommend [above] are free of oxybenzone. Just in case.
Update: Consumer Reports (2016) assures me “Some chemical UV filters, such as octinoxate and oxybenzone, have been found to cause hormonal changes in animals; however, short-term research in people did not show any adverse effect.” However, it [no doubt] make for a highly-effective sunscreen.
Therefore, if oxybenzone is not a concern for you personally, save some dollars and go with Coppertone Water Babies, Pure Sun Defense (with Disney label), and even Equate by WalMart (per Consumer Reports latest test results, 2016).
- Many sunscreens only protect from UVB rays, giving people a false sense of security about spending time in the sun. UVA radiation doesn’t cause sunburns per se, but can increase the rate of melanoma and AGING of the skin (ack!), so many people using sunscreens may be exposed to high UVA levels without realizing it.Look for sunscreens with broad-spectrum (UVA/UVB) protection (for adults too)! Natural sunscreen ingredients, including zinc oxide and titanium dioxide protect from both UVA and UVB overexposure. Do I have your back or what? Fuggetaboutit.
So go getcha some kiddie sunscreen and enjoy the summer!
Next in the Summer Series
- Part 2: Best Swim Diapers
- Part 3: Sun Protective Clothing for Kids
- Part 4: Best Insect Repellents for Kids
- Part 5: Best Life Jackets for Infants, Toddlers, and Preschoolers
- Part 6: Summer Shoes for Kids