Chances are, if you’ve had a c-section or any type of abdominal surgery, you may have used an abdominal binder during your recovery (they’re also used by women who’ve had vaginal deliveries). These binders, also known as belly wraps, compression bands, postpartum girdles, etc., encircle and compress the abdomen.
The idea is that the material protects the surgical incision, while the binder’s compression helps decrease postoperative pain (among other benefits).
But do they really “work”?
An OB-GYN from Beverly Hills explains: “We’ve been prescribing abdominal binders for a long time… with obstetrics, these wraps help women recovering from a vaginal delivery or a c-section with their posture, abdominal support, and self-confidence.”
Some even claim that abdominal binders can help close separated abdominal muscles, a condition called diastasis recti. Though this claim has not been scientifically proven, many women (self included) wear them after pregnancy in hopes it will help.
In addition to helping close separated ab muscles (or “proximate” your abs, as PTs say), other purported benefits associated with wearing abdominal binders postpartum include helping the uterus shrink back down to size, alleviating pain, increasing comfort (allowing you to walk farther and get back to doing your normal activities sooner), and protecting the c-section incision.
One thing’s for sure: they don’t help you lose fat (or actual weight).
Doctors and Studies Say…
At the end of the day, some doctors like and recommend postpartum girdles, while others think they are a complete waste of time. To make matters even more confusing, most of the research on belly bands has been done on general surgical patients, and not specifically postpartum mamas.
We looked at 3 studies to see if there was any consensus ~
- One study showed that belly bands helped users walk farther than those who didn’t use them, but did not help in the pain department. [i]
- Another study, published in the International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics in 2016, determined that belly bands made no difference: the authors reported that “postoperative pain and distress scores after cesarean delivery were not affected by abdominal binders.”[ii]
- Yet still another study, released in the same journal the following year (2017), reported that patients who used binders after c-sections did experience reduced pain and symptom distress, plus they had less blood loss.[iii]
See? Crystal clear (LOL).
A problem with all of this research on binders is the timing: so far, studies only look at results a few days post-surgery. All of the measurements from the previously discussed studies (pain scores, walking tests, etc.) were taken only 1-5 days after procedures. It makes you wonder what the longer-term positive effects of abdominal compression may be?
As an aside, I (Marissa) used an abdominal binder after both of my c-sections (note: they were given to me each time by the hospital). Personally, I really liked wearing it. It made me feel more secure when moving around (or you know, breathing), and felt like it was holding together my severed ab muscles. I also held out hope that it eventually would help heal my diastasis recti (yet here we are 18 months postpartum, and no such luck…). Bottom line: I had a good experience and wouldn’t hesitate to wear a binder again. See also: what to wear after a c-section.
As mentioned, most moms actually use the binders for everyday wear in the weeks and months beyond birth – not just in the immediate aftermath. And many women also like the support of them during pregnancy.
Women who haven’t had cesareans still like the belly support provided by products like the Nesting Days carrier. I (Meg) loved wearing the Nesting Days for this reason: it just felt good and made me sit a little taller.
The good news is that there appears to be virtually no harmful effects associated with using an abdominal binder, although the tighter binders prescribed for some of the diastasis rehab programs can cause dizziness and shortness of breath.
When I (Brittany) asked my brother – a surgical resident, and friend – an OB resident, about the use of abdominal binders, they both indicated that compression bands are really a matter of preference. Some patients don’t like them and choose not to use them even when advised, while others enjoy them. In turn, some surgeons see them as more helpful while others think they are futile.
Whether you choose to use an abdominal binder is truly up to you — they may help, and they really can’t hurt, so if you want to try it out, go for it (and then report back to us with your findings!)
If you decide to use an abdominal binder after giving birth, here are some highly-rated options:
See also what to wear home after a c-section, which includes some incision-protection underwear.
Did you know that maternity support belts are eligible for reimbursement with your FSA/HSA/HRA account?
3 in 1 Postpartum Girdle ~ $19
This girdle is affordable and highly rated. With it, you get three belts: a belly belt, a waist belt and a pelvic belt. The belly belt helps to repair abdominal muscles and claims to bring your abs back together; the waist belt aids in back pain relief and c-section incision recovery; and the pelvis belt helps relieve pelvic pain and weakness postpartum.
Belly Bandit ~ $49
Postpartum moms can wear the ever-popular Belly Bandit right away. It’s recommend that this band be worn every day, all day, for a minimum of 6-8 weeks after giving birth. Belly Bandit has a wide variety of different types and styles of bands, but they all claim to “reshape your waist, hips and belly”. Some users rave about the Belly Bandit, saying it really helped with healing and trimming the tummy, while others say it’s not worth the money.
Bellefit Postpartum Corset ~ $108
This band has a medical-grade abdominal panel that protects and helps heal the abdomen and c-section incision. The corset has adjustable front Velcro closures, as well as a flap that un-hooks at the crotch to make bathroom breaks easier (and we all know how often those occur postpartum!). Users seem to love this corset, and many note that it helped them feel more confident and less “jiggly in the belly” after giving birth.
If you try one of these, please report back your findings by leaving a comment below. Thanks!!
– Brit, Marissa and Meg
Back to Postpartum
[i] Oren Cheifetz et al., “The Effect of Abdominal Support on Functional Outcomes in Patients Following Major Abdominal Surgery: A Randomized Controlled Trial,” Physiotherapy Canada 62, no. 3 (2010): 242–53, doi:10.3138/physio.62.3.242; Emine Arici, Sevinc Tastan, and Mehmet Fatih Can, “The Effect of Using an Abdominal Binder on Postoperative Gastrointestinal Function, Mobilization, Pulmonary Function, and Pain in Patients Undergoing Major Abdominal Surgery: A Randomized Controlled Trial,” International Journal of Nursing Studies 62 (October 1, 2016): 108–17, doi:10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2016.07.017.
[ii] Christin M. Gillier et al., “A Randomized Controlled Trial of Abdominal Binders for the Management of Postoperative Pain and Distress after Cesarean Delivery,” International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics: The Official Organ of the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics 133, no. 2 (May 2016): 188–91, doi:10.1016/j.ijgo.2015.08.026.
[iii] Samieh Ghana et al., “Randomized Controlled Trial of Abdominal Binders for Postoperative Pain, Distress, and Blood Loss after Cesarean Delivery,” International Journal of Gynaecology and Obstetrics: The Official Organ of the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics 137, no. 3 (June 2017): 271–76, doi:10.1002/ijgo.12134.